Within the picture above there are two wearables. One is Fitbit’s just lately launched Cost 5, a $179.95 health tracker designed to measure all the things out of your coronary heart price to your sleep and even your pores and skin temperature. The opposite is Amazon’s new $79.99 Halo View health tracker, which Amazon says can measure all the things out of your coronary heart price to your sleep and pores and skin temperature. Ten factors when you can inform me which is which.

The Halo View was simply one among a number of recent units introduced by Amazon at its now annual fall {hardware} occasion this week. However whereas a lot of Amazon’s new merchandise function utterly unique designs and options, like its cute Astro “home robot” or Ring-branded house surveillance drone, there have been a handful that bear a hanging resemblance to preexisting merchandise.

Take Amazon’s new $59.99 good thermostat, which works with Amazon’s voice assistant Alexa, and guarantees to detect whenever you’re house and alter the temperature accordingly. That’s similar to what different Alexa-enabled thermostats just like the $250 Ecobee good thermostat supply, however at a fraction of the worth. To not point out Amazon’s design can be much like a preexisting good thermostat produced by a company called Tado (which itself retails for the equal of round $240).

Amazon’s new Sensible Thermostat.
Picture: Amazon

Not each good thermostat must look utterly unique or have a singular set of options (in any case, there’s solely a lot a thermostat can do). However the announcement of Amazon’s personal Sensible Thermostat comes simply months after The Wall Street Journal reported that Ecobee had been nervous about sharing further information with Amazon, partly as a consequence of fears that this information might assist it launch competing merchandise, as considerations that it might hurt client privateness. Ecobee was reportedly instructed that failing to offer this information, which might ship info to Amazon concerning the system’s standing even when a buyer wasn’t utilizing it, might danger the corporate dropping its Alexa certification for future fashions or not be featured in Prime Day gross sales.

In response to The Verge’s enquiry, Amazon stated it hadn’t used information from some other Alexa-connected thermostats to design its Sensible Thermostat. It stated the system had been co-created with Resideo, an organization that has additionally labored on Honeywell’s Dwelling thermostats, and that Ecobee continues to be one among its valued companions.

In the meantime, Amazon’s new Halo membership options seem like apparent opponents to MyFitnessPal. Halo Diet is designed to assist customers discover recipes and prepare dinner meals that matches their dietary wants, much like the Meal Plans feature MyFitnessPal already contains as a part of its premium plan. There’s additionally Halo Health’ guided exercises, much like the self-guided routines from MyFitnessPal. However Amazon’s well being subscription is quite a bit cheaper than MyFitnessPal’s premium tier. Amazon features a free 12 months of its Halo membership companies with the acquisition of its new Halo View health tracker, and it retails for $3.99 / month thereafter, which is lower than half the worth of MyFitnessPal’s $9.99 premium tier.

After we requested Amazon about these similarities, it stated it had not copied different firms, and that its Halo service contains distinctive options not accessible with different health trackers.

Responding to questions from The Verge, Amazon stated it’s “pioneered hundreds of features, products, and even entirely new categories” all through its historical past. “Amazon’s ideas are our own,” the corporate stated, citing merchandise such because the Kindle, Amazon Echo, and Fireplace TV as outstanding examples of its unique innovations.

I’m not making an attempt to assert that Amazon is breaking any guidelines with these merchandise. There are solely so some ways you possibly can design a display screen that straps to your wrist and reveals you your coronary heart price — even when this one has clear Fitbit vibes — or a panel that attaches in your wall to manage the temperature. Even difficult units like smartphones have seen their designs step by step converge through the years, a course of not helped by the truth that many producers are utilizing parts equipped by the identical small handful of firms.

However the similarities look cynical coming from Amazon, which has been criticized for ripping off the designs of merchandise bought on its platform after which undercutting them on value. Earlier this 12 months, bag and accent producer Peak Design drew consideration to the startling similarity between its $99.95 On a regular basis Sling and Amazon Fundamentals’ $32.99 Digicam Bag, for instance. Amazon’s model of the bag has since been discontinued, the corporate instructed The Verge.

Peak Design’s bag subsequent to a really related mannequin from Amazon.
Picture: Peak Design

Amazon’s cloning of the Peak Design bag wasn’t an remoted incident, both. In 2019, hanging similarities have been additionally identified between the $45 sneakers produced by Amazon’s 206 Collective label and Allbirds’ $95 equal. The similarities prompted Allbirds CEO Joey Zwillinger to respond in a Medium post saying that he was “flattered at the similarities that your private label shoe shares with ours,” however politely requested that Amazon additionally “steal our approach to sustainability” and use equally renewable supplies. Amazon stated that the shoe has additionally since been discontinued, however that it continues to supply related types. Amazon additionally stated its unique design didn’t infringe on Allbirds’ design, and that the aesthetic is widespread throughout the business.

Or what concerning the Amazon Fundamentals Laptop computer Stand that Bloomberg reported on in 2016, which was launched at round half the worth of Rain Design’s (on the time) bestselling $43 mannequin? Harvey Tai, Rain Design’s common supervisor, stated that the corporate’s gross sales had slipped since Amazon’s competing mannequin appeared on the shop, though he admitted that “there’s nothing we can do because they didn’t violate the patent.”

Copying and trying to undercut dominant market gamers is nothing new. However Amazon is in a reasonably distinctive place in that it’s not simply competing with these merchandise; in loads of instances, it’s additionally promoting them by way of its personal platform. That theoretically offers it entry to a goldmine of knowledge which may very well be invaluable if it needed to launch a competitor of its personal.

Amazon was accused of doing precisely this in a Wall Street Journal investigation final 12 months, which alleged that Amazon’s workers “have used data about independent sellers on the company’s platform to develop competing products.” The WSJ particularly cited an occasion the place an unnamed Amazon private-label worker accessed detailed gross sales information a few car-trunk organizer from an organization known as Fortem launched in 2016. In 2019, Amazon launched three related opponents underneath its Amazon Fundamentals label.

The identical report additionally detailed an occasion of workers accessing gross sales information for a preferred office-chair seat cushion from Higher Echelon Merchandise, earlier than Amazon launched its personal competitor.

Amazon tells The Verge that an inside investigation carried out following the publication of the WSJ’s report discovered no violations of its insurance policies prohibiting using private particular person vendor information.

Whether or not or not Amazon’s workers are breaking its guidelines, regulators have taken discover. Final 12 months the EU accused Amazon of utilizing “non-public seller data” to tell Amazon’s personal retail presents and enterprise choices. “Data on the activity of third party sellers should not be used to the benefit of Amazon when it acts as a competitor to these sellers,” the European Fee’s antitrust tzar, Margrethe Vestager, stated on the time. The Fee has but to concern a last report or findings, and in an announcement Amazon stated it disagreed with its accusations.

For its half, Amazon says it has a coverage of stopping its workers from utilizing “nonpublic, seller-specific data to determine which private label products to launch.” However the firm’s founder and former CEO Jeff Bezos instructed lawmakers final 12 months that he couldn’t assure the coverage has by no means been violated, and sources interviewed by The Wall Avenue Journal stated that workers discovered methods round these guidelines.

These accusations have up to now centered round low-tech gadgets like baggage, sneakers, and trunk organizers. However as Amazon has expanded into extra areas of client tech, its designs are as soon as once more straying very near the competitors.

Given these considerations, it appears particularly weird that Amazon was keen to reference the worth of competing good thermostats bought by way of its platform through the launch. Its good thermostat is “less than half the average cost of a smart thermostat sold on Amazon.com,” the corporate’s senior vice chairman of units and companies, Dave Limp, stated.

As soon as once more, I must stress that there’s nothing unlawful (to my data) about utilizing public info like pricing with a purpose to inform your individual merchandise. However taking a second to particularly reference the pricing of competing units bought by yourself monolithic on-line retailer is an odd selection within the midst of all this scrutiny.

Will probably be unattainable to know the way carefully the performance of every of Amazon’s new merchandise are to their opponents till we’ve tried them for ourselves. However given Amazon’s dimension and market energy, these sorts of awkward questions should be requested. In any case, Amazon is treading a clumsy line between working one of many largest gross sales platforms on the earth, and competing inside them as an more and more prolific client tech producer. It’s a troublesome steadiness, and regulators are watching.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here