When the film Pricey Evan Hansen works, it’s working in opposition to the unique musical’s platitudes and giving weight to its inherent brutality.
Picture: Erika Doss/Common Photos

When you have heard one factor in regards to the film musical Pricey Evan Hansen, it’s most likely that the star is just too outdated. “Old” on this case means “in his late 20s,” and regardless of an extended historical past of creaky elderpersons enjoying teenagers onscreen (cf. Bye Bye Birdie and Riverdale), for a lot of, the casting of a closely made-up, 27-year-old Ben Platt has been one uncanny valley too far. Our Vulture protection from the Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition requested the exhausting query — “How Old Does Ben Platt Look in Dear Evan Hansen?” — and the reply was: so outdated. I can confirm. Comparisons to Pat from SNL’s “It’s Pat!” and the kid impersonator in Orphan are usually not incorrect. I’d add that Platt’s Evan Hansen seems like Fred Armisen in any sketch by which Fred Armisen is making an attempt to appear additional naïve and creepy.

And, sorry, however I’m type of into it? The stage undertaking was constructed round and for Platt’s ethereal voice, which is one half pop-Broadway, one half Vienna Boys Choir. But the precise content material of the musical is distressing, messy, filled with psychological manipulation and passive aggression. It’s due to this fact sort of … helpful that we now have to wrestle to reconcile Platt’s angelic sound to his waxwork face. When the film Pricey Evan Hansen provides dimension to the stage model, it does so by working in opposition to the unique’s platitudes and giving extra weight to its inherent brutality. The musical’s sometimes-smeary qualities are burned off by the sheer weirdness of Platt’s makes an attempt to “act” away a decade of human getting old, that are exaggerated, typically to the purpose of comedy. His apparent “wrongness” makes senseless sympathy with the character a problem; it turns any compassion you do muster for him right into a (productively) troublesome act.

As a result of pricey little Evan has actually completed one thing terrible. In Steven Levenson’s script (and Benj Pasek and Justin Paul’s songs), the socially anxious Evan — by means of a maze of coincidences and accidents — winds up pretending to have a friendship with fellow pupil Connor (Colton Ryan), who has died by suicide. The letter that begins “Dear Evan Hansen” is definitely written by Evan himself as a remedy train. The troubled Connor finds the letter on a faculty printer, then has it with him at his dying, at which level it’s mistaken for a letter between true confidants.

Levenson is a elaborate plotter, and a fast one, so he quickly snares Evan into promising increasingly to Connor’s grieving household, together with his mom Cynthia (Amy Adams) and crushable sister Zoe (Kaitlyn Dever). Can Evan produce extra proof of his nonexistent friendship with Connor? If he groups up with pc wiz Jared (Nik Dodani), he can. As soon as Evan speaks at a faculty meeting about what Connor “taught” him, singing the beautiful “You Will Be Found,” he goes viral, will get standard, will get the lady:

Even when the darkish comes crashing by means of

If you want a pal to hold you

And whenever you’re damaged on the bottom

You may be discovered.

Wham! The cynicism guillotines by means of you, prime to toe. In his track, Evan is rewriting an episode from his personal life, when he fell from a tree and nobody helped him. However that is how the world is: You gained’t truly be discovered, however folks will revenue from mendacity about that whenever you die. Key change!

Monstrous conduct occurs in musicals (extrajudicial killing in Oklahoma!, spousal abuse in Carousel), however music has the facility to cue our feelings any which approach — the melody swells and our sentiments observe. In Pricey Evan Hansen, Evan’s conduct verges on sociopathy, but songwriters Pasek and Paul give him such heartrending arias, expressing such a depth of feeling, that the theatrical viewers empathizes with Evan’s damage and never the damage he’s induced. And he has a lot ache to plumb! Evan’s introductory track “Waving Through a Window” is an anthem for all folks anyplace who really feel alienated from the bustling world. “Step out, step out of the sun / If you keep getting burned,” he sings, already, at 17, too damage by life to dwell it. Director Stephen Chbosky levels the track fantastically, taking it from Evan’s room to the college, the place the inevitable key change hits simply as he bursts by means of a set of cafeteria doorways. That magnetic, musical pull towards Evan is at work in Chbosky’s film model. However now the pull is coupled with a robust pushin different phrases, repulsion — that retains us from being seduced.

Not that the film isn’t making an attempt to seduce us. The film’s textures are high-quality and wealthy: Cinematographer Brandon Trost lingers on the dappled eggshell surfaces of Connor’s household home, so totally different from the home the place Evan and his harried single mom — performed by Julianne Moore — are scraping by. Even at Evan’s, although, the colours are luscious, deeply shadowed greens and blues. He loves the woods, and Connor cherished an orchard, and you may see a wooden’s bosky tones filtering by means of their homes. Chbosky’s sound division does a powerful job of creating the songs match into these areas, so when Dever’s Zoe sings to Evan, she appears to be doing it in an actual child’s room, slightly than a dubbing studio. Dever additionally does a superb job of exhibiting us how hostile and bewildered and ugly a grieving individual may be. Amy Adams, alternatively, suffers beatifically.

Levenson and the remainder have lower some songs, reordered others, and rejiggered the ending. (The film model of the story now makes certain that Evan atones, although it nonetheless options slightly an excessive amount of teary nodding for my style.) Many of the songs for adults are gone, although Julianne Moore nonetheless sings a track of forgiveness to her son —“So Big / So Small” — on the coronary heart of the film. Her face, clearly not made as much as look youthful than it’s, shines like a lighthouse, and her voice, with its sweetly ragged, unconfident edge, turns into an important factor within the movie. There’s a brand new track for Connor and one for a fragile classmate performed by Amandla Stenberg, who can also be utilizing Connor’s dying for her personal functions. You’ll actually not belief a high-school pupil so far as you possibly can throw one after this film, however additionally, you will come away with the impression that they’re all teetering on the sting — by my depend, 4 of the 5 children we meet are on the point of self-harm.

The film’s model of adolescence is clearly only a tub of ache, and Pricey Evan Hansen (like Chbosky’s personal ebook, The Perks of Being a Wallflower) sinks us into that anguish so deeply it turns right into a bizarre, vicarious pain-pleasure. There’s one thing to consider there: the dominance of artworks made by adults that amplify excessive teenage sorrow. Are we hungry for an emotional scale we will now not attain? Did any of us truly recover from our adolescence? And that’s why I’m grateful for the un-teen, undead face of Ben Platt. As a lot as Pricey Evan Hansen speaks to the youngs and makes the olds cry, it’s price remembering that there’s some emotional vampirism occurring right here. It’s high-quality, high-quality, to make artwork that does this! We do draw sustenance from each other’s blood. It’s simply good to be sincere in regards to the gruesomeness of it — a reminder of the yuck, which doesn’t obviate the yum.

Extra Film Opinions

  • Let Nicolas Cage Information You Via the Insanity of Prisoners of the Ghostland

  • The Eyes of Tammy Faye Is All Eyelashes, No Tooth

  • Spencer Is a Portrait of a Princess Too Sane to Play the Royals’ Recreation

See All


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here